Monday, October 13, 2008

For the undecided voter

My daughter is participating in a mock election. For the first part--the nomination process, if you will, she had to answer three of four questions. Right now, my heart is breaking for missing homeschooling, because I have missed her enthusiasm for learning.

1. What qualities make a great President? Use examples of past presidents to prove your point of view.

A quality of a president is optimism. Herbert Hoover was almost optimistic when the Depression hit. Also, FDR was optimistic. When he gave out the New Deal, he was optimistic that it would work.

2. What issues do you see in this school that require student leadership? How would you try to solve them?

I do not see anything wrong with this school except the food. There should be more and healthier food and less junk food. It may be crazy, but if they're serving junk food, make it Italian pizza. That's healthy. I have Italian ancestors.

3. Why is it important for people to vote?
(she opted not to answer this one)

4. Who would you vote for in the 2008 Presidential Election and why? (Please give at least 3 good reasons with details.)


John McCain would be a good president, because when he was serving in the Vietnam War, when he was captured and made prisoner, when he was asked if he wanted early release, and he said "No." That was serving our country. McCain has had 25 years in Congress, whereas Obama has only four years in Congress. McCain wants to let parents choose schools for their children.
~~~
She wrote this essay with very little coaching. I did remind her that she knew of some former presidents, because she has read the American Girls books. We looked at the campaign websites for both candidates; I tried to get her to be skeptical of what she read. But she came to her own decision.

Too bad her aunt's head will explode when she reads it.

6 comments:

Willow said...

Auntie's and mine. Poor child. ;D

Bill said...

Her reasoning is pretty sound for someone her age. Unfortunately, 45% of adult Americans reason at the same level...

Star said...

She is better informed than many adults I know. Maybe they should do away with age estrictions on voting and administer those 4 questionss as a tes to qualify.

Margaret said...

***SPLAT***

Cute essay, though. Except for those two words. I know you made her do it. I'll set her straight when I get there. Hope she is disappointed.

birdy said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
birdy said...

(sorry, last comment didn't make sense... new keyboard and my fingers are acting confused!)

So, what did she think of the election results?